News

Hawaiʻi County Council passes long-debated rules for hosted, unhosted short-term rentals

Published November 19, 2026 • 5:00 AM HST Updated November 19, 2026 • 8:19 AM HST
Text size:
Listen to this Article
4 minutes4 min
Loading Audio... Article will play after ad...
Playing in :00
Comments

After months of delays, deferred votes and amendments, the Hawaiʻi County Council has passed the fourth draft of a bill that clarifies operational standards and defines what constitutes a short-term rental. 

Bill 147 classifies short term rentals as hosted and unhosted, establishes in which zoning districts they can operate, and extends the rental period considered short-term to anything under 180 days instead of under 30 days. 

It also establishes punitive fines for violations, which will go toward the creation of an enforcement fund. 

Although much of the public testimony has been in opposition, Council Member Heather Kimball said the bill is meant to simplify the process for rental owners and the County of Hawaiʻi Planning Department. By passing Bill 147, rental owners in certain zoning districts won’t have to apply for use permits under new registration requirements that recently went into effect.

As of Sept. 1 , rental owners are required to register their properties with the county under Ordinance 20-25.

“In the Planning Department, we are without clear guidance in the zoning code,” said Jeff Darrow, director of the Planning Department. “Before this bill passes, every hosted transient vacation rental registering would require a use permit or special permit.

“We have been holding off enforcement and holding off on directing residents to come in for a permit, but the staff are looking toward this bill to bring direction and guidance through the registration process.”

During the last council meeting on Nov. 6, testifiers expressed concern with the enforcement and asked for warnings before fines are assessed.

“Mahalo for allowing owners to receive a notice and date to a correct the problem,” Nicholas Lepisto testified. “That addition was fair and a good faith step for those who are affected by the bill.”

The first violation is a $5,500, a second violation is $7,500 and any subsequent violation is $10,000. 

The fourth draft of the bill now includes that the Planning Director shall first issue a warning letter to the owner of the transient vacation rental that identifies the chapter that was violated, the factual basis for the violation, and the penalties that may be assessed.

The owner is then given time to cease and desist from the violation, correct the violation or submit a written response with any supporting information that the violation did not occur, or has been corrected. 

The planning director will verify before assessing an administrative fine and the director may assess an administrative fine for each day in which the violation persists. 

“I was once in opposition of the bill, but after all the amendments and discussions, I know that there are many professionals in the industry are content with the changes that have been made,” said Clark Kahawaiʻi, who works in professional vacation rental management for Elite Pacific Vacations . “I do appreciate the changes that have been made to the enforcement and giving people warnings.”

The bill also lists the general provisions required by the transient vacation rental, responsible management, good neighbor policy, advertising rules and the operational standards that the transient vacation rental must meet.

Before the bill passed, testifiers were worried that they would lose income and be unable to operate their rental due to zoning or heavy fines, but Kimball reiterated that the bill allows the county to maintain the current status quo for short-term rentals. 

During his testimony, Kahawaiʻi urged the County Council and the Planning Department to provide education to the public regarding the new rules.

“It’s impossible to make everyone happy, but I think it would be made better if there was some education provided to residents,” Kahawaiʻi said. “There are specifics that aren’t solidified. If professionals that are experts in renting homes in Hawaiʻi are confused, then I’m sure that’s even more the case for the public. Having as clear a process as possible is definitely necessary.”

The bill states that hosted transient vacation rentals are permited in the following zoning districts:

  • Single-Family Residential
  • Double-Family Residential
  • Multiple-Family Residential
  • Residential-Commercial Mixed Use
  • Resort
  • Neighborhood Commercial
  • General Commercial
  • Village Commercial
  • Downtown Hilo Commercial
  • Project District
  • Any agricultural district except Intensive Agricultural

Unhosted transient vacation rentals are permitted in the following zoning districts:

  • Vacation
  • General Commercial
  • Village Commercial
  • Downtown Hilo Commercial
  • Neighborhood Commercial or any residential district, provided that the building site is wholly situated within a Resort, or Resort Node area noted in the General Plan
  • Project District where consistent with the uses allowed in the underlying zoning district
  • Multiple-Family Residential as long as the plan approval or a building permit for the dwelling used as the un-hosted transient vacation rental was issued prior to the effective date of this ordinance

Any zoning district not identified can operate an un-hosted transient vacation rental with a nonconforming use certificate or with a use permit.

ADVERTISEMENT
Kelsey Walling
Kelsey Walling is a journalist for Big Island Now and Pacific Media Group. She graduated from the University of Missouri School of Journalism and has been a working photojournalist and news writer for nine years, five of which have been on Hawaiʻi Island. Kelsey can be reached at kelsey.walling@pmghawaii.com.


Read Full Bio

Sponsored Content

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay in-the-know with daily or weekly
headlines delivered straight to your inbox.
Cancel
×

Comments

This comments section is a public community forum for the purpose of free expression. Although Big Island Now encourages respectful communication only, some content may be considered offensive. Please view at your own discretion. View Comments