Kagiwada wins Hawai’i County Council District 2 seat; three County Charter amendments approved
Update: With less than 650 ballots left outstanding islandwide, Jennifer Kagiwada will be the new representative for District 2 on the Hawai‘i County Council. According to the unofficial results, Kagiwada had 4,244 votes, or 48.3%, compared to the 3,974 votes, or 45.2%, for Matthias Kusch as of 4:40 a.m. Wednesday.
The Hawai‘i County Office of the County Clerk Elections Division said Thursday that there are only 621 ballots from around the island — not just District 2 — that were returned via mail that had an “envelope deficiency” of some kind, most likely a signature issue, which those voters have five business days after Tuesday’s election, or until Nov. 16, to cure and return to be counted, if they choose.
Kagiwada, who currently works as the legislative assistant for District 1 Councilwoman Heather Kimball, will replace current Council Vice Chairman Aaron Chung, who is term limited.
She said Thursday that she is grateful for the opportunity to work for the people of Hilo and Hawai’i County.
“I am inspired to be part of a County Council made up of seven talented, hard-working women and a couple of wonderful, collaborative men who will support each other’s district goals while pulling in the same direction to tackle the major islandwide issues facing our community,” Kagiwada said.
She will be one of three new faces on the next Council. Michelle Galimba will replace outgoing Council Chairwoman Maile David, who also is term limited, and Cindy Evans will take over the District 9 seat currently occupied by Tim Richards, who won the state Senate District 4 seat in Tuesday’s election. Galimba and Evans won their seats in the August primary.
The rest of the Council seats will remain filled by incumbents, who also won in the primary: Kimball; Sue Lee Loy, District 3; Ashley Kierkiewicz, District 4; Matt Kaneali‘i-Kleinfelder, District 5; Rebecca Villegas, District 7; and Holeka Inaba, District 8.
The new Council will be sworn in at noon Dec. 5.
Kagiwada said her first order of business will be to staff her office and create communication channels with the residents of District 2 so that Hilo residents feel they have a voice in their community.
“Mahalo for putting your trust in me,” she said.
Kagiwada also thanked her “worthy opponent,” Kusch, for working hard on the campaign trail and pushing her to work even harder. Kusch called Kagiwada on Thursday morning to offer his congratulations after seeing the final read out of results.
“While obviously disappointed, it’s been an incredible experience and the outpouring of support by so many is both humbling and overwhelming,” he said. “I will continue forward, making an impact on an individual basis and the community at large by creating affordable housing, the Downtown Hilo Business Improvement District and, of course, Hilo Bayfront Trails.”
His only regret is that he will not be able to make a greater impact as a member of the Council.
“I wish Jennifer the best of luck and I would imagine at some point we’ll be collaborating together on one of the aforementioned projects in the future,” Kusch said.
Original story: Only one of the nine Hawai‘i County Council seats is up for grabs in the 2022 General Election: District 2, which features political newcomers Jennifer Kagiwada and Matthias Kusch. Only 40 votes separated them in the primary election.
As of 4:40 a.m. Wednesday, Kagiwada received 4,244 votes (48.3%) to lead Kucsh by 270 votes. Kusch has received 3,974 votes (45.2%).
The winner will replace Aaron Chung, who is term-limited.
District 2 is comprised of a portion of South Hilo that includes Downtown Hilo, Bayfront, Wailoa, a portion of Waiākea Houselots, University Heights, Komohana Gardens, a portion of Waiākea-Uka, Lanakila, Mohouli, Ainako, Ka‘ūmana, Pi‘ihonua, Wailuku and Waiānuenue.
Kagiwada, a Pi‘ihonua resident who has lived in the district for about nine years, works as the legislative assistant for District 1 Councilwoman Heather Kimball. She and her husband, Geoff Bower, have two children.
“Obviously, I’m very pleased and excited about the results so far,” Kagiwada said Tuesday night, adding she knew it would be pretty close because she and her opponent were putting the work in to connect with voters in the district.
Since March, she has been going door-to-door to meet and speak with voters. It provided the opportunity to listen to the people of the district and hear their concerns and possible solutions.
“It was not only beneficial for the campaign but also for me,” Kagiwada said.
She said if she is elected the next council member for District 2, she has a lot of stories and information to work with.
“I’m happy that the hard work part really did pay off,” Kagiwada said. “I had a plan, I stuck to it. I didn’t have as much money as my opponent, but I really think the work and going door-to-door really paid off.”
While all the votes have yet to be counted and the race is tight, she feels good about where things stand now. She thinks, if elected, she and the other Council members can come together to solve some big issues Hawai‘i County faces and looks forward to working with them.
“I’m excited for it,” Kagiwada said.
Kusch, a former first responder, retired in 2020 as a battalion chief after 25 years of service with the Hawai‘i Fire Department. He and his wife, Sunita, have three children.
Big Island Now also called Kusch on Tuesday night; however, he was unavailable for comment.
Eight of the nine council seats were decided in the August primary.
Michelle Galimba will fill the District 6 seat vacated by outgoing Council Chairwoman Maile David, who also is term limited. Cindy Evans will take over the District 9 seat currently occupied by Tim Richards, who is seeking the state Senate District 4 seat.
The rest of the Council seats remain filled by incumbents, who also won in the Aug. 13 primary: Heather Kimball, District 1; Sue Lee Loy, District 3; Ashley Kierkiewicz, District 4; Matt Kaneali‘i-Kleinfelder, District 5; Rebecca Villegas, District 7; and Holeka Inaba, District 8.
Hawai’i County residents also Tuesday voted on three Charter Amendments.
Proposal No. 1: Membership for the Board of Ethics
Shall the Hawai‘i County Charter be amended to increase the membership of the Board
of Ethics from five members to seven members?
The proposed amendment was introduced by Councilmember Susan L.K. Lee Loy in May. The Board of Ethics had requested an increase in numbers in order to ensure a quorum for meetings, which had become a problem during the COVID-19 pandemic, and help with its workload.
Voters approved the amendment, with 35,157 (54.4%) voting yes and 23,937 (37.1%) voting no.
Proposal No 2: Expanding the Duties of the County Auditor
Shall the Hawai‘i County Charter be amended to expand the duties of the Office of the
County Auditor to include investigating allegations of fraud, waste or abuse within the
operations of the County of Hawai‘i?
Councilmember Ashley Lehualani Kierkiewicz introduced the amendment after realizing that tips and information obtained from the county’s 2022 pilot whistleblower program could not be investigated by the county auditor because the charter “actually restricts” it.
The amendment was approved, with 50,777 (78.6%) voting yes and 9,228 (14.3%) voting no.
Proposal No. 3: Establishing a Youth Commission
Shall the Hawai‘i County Charter be amended to establish a Youth Commission, which
would consist of at least nine but no more than 15 members between the ages of 14 and
24-years old, whose duties would include advising the Mayor, County Council, and
official agencies of the County on legislative and budgetary matters, assess existing
programs and advance new programs that support youth development, and encourage and
coordinate youth participation in County initiatives and other forms of civic engagement?
Councilmember Kierkiewicz also introduced Proposal No. 3. It was modeled after a similar commission created in the city and county of Honolulu two years ago and other similar commissions around the country.
This amendment was also approved, with 39,835 (61.7%) voting yes and 20,178 (31.2%) voting no.
No candidates or contests match your filters.
Maui: Independent Nomination Board
-
32 27.8%YES
-
28 24.3%NO
State Senator, Dist 9
-
18 51.4%CHANG, Stanley
-
15 42.9%CROSWELL, David A.
State Representative, Dist 49
-
0 0.0%MATAYOSHI, Scot
-
0 0.0%RODAS, 'Ale
Councilmember (Makawao-Haiku-Paia)
-
37 32.2%CHUNG, Stevie Kathryn
-
30 26.1%U'U-HODGINS, Nohe
Councilmember (Molokai)
-
54 47.0%RAWLINS-FERNANDEZ, Keani
State Representative, Dist 34
-
0 0.0%DUPIO, Gaius, II (Kipi)
-
0 0.0%TAKAYAMA, Gregg
Councilmember, Dist IV
-
51 60.0%GREGORY, Tara Malia
-
33 38.8%OZAWA, Trevor
Charter Question #3
Should an Office of ʻŌiwi Resources and Cultural Stewardship be established within the Office of the Mayor to oversee the management of ʻŌiwi resources within the City, develop related programs, and create a Cultural Advisory Council of kūpuna, cultural practitioners, and community representatives?
-
143 48.8%NO
-
99 33.8%YES
State Representative, Dist 14
-
0 0.0%COCHRAN, Elle
-
0 0.0%KIAKONA, Pa'ele
-
0 0.0%PATEL, Sne
Charter Question #1
Should the Charter require annual funding for a Food Security Fund, without having to simultaneously increase real property tax rates to fund the appropriation, to support programs and grants that provide locally grown or produced food to Oahu residents, as well as non-local food only in an emergency?
-
143 48.8%NO
-
105 35.8%YES
Charter Question #18
Should the First Deputy of the Department of Human Resources be exempt from civil service provisions, like similar roles in other City departments?
-
136 46.4%YES
-
104 35.5%NO
Charter Question #4
Should a nine-member LGBTQIA+ Commission be established to advise the Mayor, City Council, and City agencies on matters affecting the LGBTQIA+ community and recommend policies, programs, and legislation promoting social, economic, and political equality?
-
154 52.6%NO
-
95 32.4%YES
Charter Question #13
Should the Charter be amended to allow the Clean Water and Natural Lands Fund to be used for historic preservation, and to preserve and protect buildings, sites, structures, and objects that have been acquired by the fund; to rename the Fund the Land, Natural Resources, and Historic Preservation Fund, and the advisory commission for the Fund the Land, Natural Resources, and Historic Preservation advisory commission; and to allocate proposal review for Fund use between the advisory commission and the Oʻahu Historic Preservation Commission?
-
146 49.8%NO
-
103 35.2%YES
Councilmember (East Maui)
-
43 37.4%SINENCI, Shane
-
33 28.7%CARROLL, Claire Kamalu
State Representative, Dist 30
-
0 0.0%TEMPLO, Shirley Ann
-
0 0.0%YBANEZ, Amanda
Maui: Reappointment of Members of the Board of Ethics
-
31 27.0%YES
-
28 24.3%NO
Relating to the Planning Commission's Appeals Process
-
14 43.8%YES
-
6 18.8%NO
State Representative, Dist 8
-
0 0.0%PERREIRA, Monique
-
0 0.0%TARNAS, David A.
Councilmember, Dist 5
-
4 44.4%MATSON, Shannon Lopeka
-
4 44.4%RODENHURST, Ikaika
State Representative, Dist 13
-
35 70.0%POEPOE, Mahina
-
9 18.0%VANDERPOOL, Robin D.
Maui Mayor
-
77 67.0%BISSEN, Richard T., Jr.
-
32 27.8%SUGIMURA, Yuki Lei Kashiwa
Councilmember (West Maui)
-
45 39.1%PALTIN, Tamara Akiko Maile
-
30 26.1%TILLMAN, Mark
Councilmember (Wailuku-Waihee-Waikapu)
-
40 34.8%MONIZ, Marvin
-
35 30.4%LINDSEY, Ashley Awakea
Councilmember (Kahului)
-
48 41.7%KAMEKONA, Carol Lee
-
29 25.2%BATANGAN, Kauanoe
Councilmember (South Maui)
-
44 38.3%COOK, Tom
-
41 35.7%KING, Kelly Takaya
Councilmember (Upcountry)
-
54 47.0%PAHIA, Bobby
-
24 20.9%YOKOUCHI, Jon Masaru
Councilmember (Lanai)
-
54 47.0%JOHNSON, Gabe
Maui: Planning Commission Review of General Plan and Land Use Ordinances
-
35 30.4%YES
-
27 23.5%NO
Maui: Standardizing Deadlines for Voter Initiative, Recall, and Charter Amendment
-
37 32.2%YES
-
27 23.5%NO
Maui: Computation of Time
-
33 28.7%YES
-
26 22.6%NO
Maui: Processing of Claims
-
33 28.7%YES
-
25 21.7%NO
Maui: Removing the English Translation of the Hawai'i State Motto
-
44 38.3%NO
-
22 19.1%YES
Maui: Emergency Appropriations
-
34 29.6%NO
-
29 25.2%YES
State Representative, Dist 10
-
17 68.0%MIYAKE, Tyson K.
-
6 24.0%BUMANGLAG, Travis
State Representative, Dist 11
-
0 0.0%AMATO, Terez (T.Amato)
-
0 0.0%WALKER, Sheila
State Representative, Dist 12
-
0 0.0%JOHNSON, Dan
-
0 0.0%YAMASHITA, Kyle T.
Maui Resident Trustee
-
271 48.8%KAPU, Ke'eaumoku
-
176 31.7%LINDSEY, Carmen Hulu
Governor and Lieutenant Governor
-
257 46.3%GREEN, Josh KAWAKAMI, Derek S.K.
-
227 40.9%CORDERY, Gary ANTHONY, Daniel
U.S. Representative, Dist II
-
129 54.7%TOKUDA, Jill N.
-
73 30.9%AWA, Brenton
At-Large Trustee
-
226 13.9%AKINA, Adrian (Kealii)
-
213 13.1%ANDERSON, Ikaika
-
200 12.3%CRABBE, Kanekoa (Koa)
-
140 8.6%GALUTERIA, Brickwood M.
-
126 7.8%WAIHEE, John, IV
-
122 7.5%SOUZA, Keoni
Oahu Resident Trustee
-
238 42.9%AKAKA, Kalei
-
180 32.4%WONG, Hinaleimoana (Hina)
Question #1
-
229 41.3%NO
-
199 35.9%YES
Question #2
-
233 42.0%NO
-
196 35.3%YES
U.S. Representative, Dist I
-
107 33.5%LAM, Adriel C.
-
93 29.2%CASE, Ed
-
60 18.8%BERNING, Nathan M.
-
26 8.2%CONLEY, Jordan S.
State Senator, Dist 2
-
7 46.7%FOGEL, Frederick F.
-
7 46.7%SAN BUENAVENTURA, Joy
State Senator, Dist 13
-
0 0.0%CHRISTIAN, Wallyn Kanoelani
-
0 0.0%NAKAMATSU, Tricia Kwai Lin
State Senator, Dist 18 (Vacancy)
-
28 80.0%KITASHIMA, Kelly Puamailani
-
6 17.1%BASS, Danielle Maliekekai
-
1 2.9%HANNA, Max G.
State Senator, Dist 19 (Vacancy)
-
10 40.0%LAMOSAO, Rachele F.
-
0 0.0%PIERICK, Elijah
State Senator, Dist 20
-
16 39.0%MCDERMOTT, Bob
-
16 39.0%OWENS, Markus
State Representative, Dist 2
-
4 44.4%KENNEALY, Jonathan
-
4 44.4%KEOHOKAPU LEE LOY, Sue
State Representative, Dist 3
-
18 60.0%TODD, Christopher L.T.
-
11 36.7%MARTIN, Austin
State Representative, Dist 4
-
0 0.0%ILAGAN, Greggor
-
0 0.0%WITTENHAGEN, Zak
State Representative, Dist 5
-
7 46.7%KAPELA, Jeanne
-
6 40.0%MCCORMICK, Dalene
State Representative, Dist 16
-
8 33.3%EVSLIN, Luke A.
-
7 29.2%HAZLEBECK, David
State Representative, Dist 17
-
0 0.0%CLUETT, Misty
-
0 0.0%MORIKAWA, Daynette (Dee)
State Representative, Dist 18
-
38 63.3%GEDEON, Joe
-
21 35.0%WATARU, James (Jamie)
State Representative, Dist 20
-
0 0.0%ASING, David
-
0 0.0%NAKADA GRANDINETTI, Tina
State Representative, Dist 23
-
0 0.0%MUH, Victor
-
0 0.0%OLDS, Ikaika M.
State Representative, Dist 26
-
0 0.0%ROSS, Ian M.A.
-
0 0.0%SILVA, Tony
State Representative, Dist 29
-
0 0.0%ABALOS, Tess
-
0 0.0%HUSSEY, Ikaika
State Representative, Dist 31
-
0 0.0%ICHIYAMA, Linda
-
0 0.0%VALDEZ, Nancy
State Representative, Dist 32
-
0 0.0%AIU, Micah Pookela Kim
-
0 0.0%SHIMIZU, Garner M.
State Representative, Dist 39
-
23 46.0%DEGRACIA, Daniel (Danny)
-
12 24.0%ROSENLEE, Corey
State Representative, Dist 40
-
4 25.0%MARTINEZ, Rose
-
4 25.0%REYES ODA, Julie
State Representative, Dist 42
-
0 0.0%GARCIA, Diamond
-
0 0.0%PARIS, Anthony Makana
State Representative, Dist 43
-
0 0.0%MEDEIROS, Sheila
-
0 0.0%SOUZA, Kanani
State Representative, Dist 44
-
0 0.0%KILA, Darius K.
-
0 0.0%WEAVER, Charla (Kahealani)
State Representative, Dist 45
-
0 0.0%KAOPUA, Kalehua
-
0 0.0%MURAOKA, Chris
State Representative, Dist 46
-
8 53.3%PERRUSO, Amy A.
-
7 46.7%GABRIEL, Daniel Michael
State Representative, Dist 47
-
0 0.0%QUINLAN, Sean
-
0 0.0%TALAEAI, Mark
State Representative, Dist 50
-
0 0.0%FITZGERALD, Jesse W.M.
-
0 0.0%LEE, Mike
Mayor
-
22 68.8%RAPOZO, Mel
-
8 25.0%CARVALHO, Bernard, Jr.
Councilmember
-
24 11.7%HOLLAND, Fern Anuenue
-
17 8.3%KANESHIRO, Arryl J.
-
12 5.8%BULOSAN, Addison
-
8 3.9%APPLEGATE, Paul Noboru
-
6 2.9%COOTS, Mike
-
6 2.9%CORREA, Michelle Kaleiohi
-
5 2.4%OZAKI, Todd R.
-
4 1.9%KAIMINAAUAO, Keola
-
4 1.9%SHIGEMOTO, Taylor H.
-
3 1.5%DECOSTA, Billy D.
-
3 1.5%MARTIN, Umi
-
3 1.5%MATTOS, John H. (Scooby)
-
2 1.0%RAPOZO, Cheree
-
2 1.0%SMITH, Dane
Councilmember, Dist 4
-
0 0.0%ENRIQUEZ, Lloyd K.
-
0 0.0%OHARA, Eileen
Councilmember, Dist 6
-
4 40.0%AKI, Zed Kaapana
-
4 40.0%ENRIQUES, Guy
Councilmember, Dist VI
-
0 0.0%DOS SANTOS-TAM, Tyler
-
0 0.0%MORIHARA, Corey
1. Hawai'i: County Auditor's Power to Employ
-
41 46.1%YES
-
38 42.7%NO
Charter Question #2
Should the Charter be amended to replace its preamble with language recognizing the relationship between the people of the City and County of Honolulu and the ʻāina, honoring the wisdom of kūpuna and the legacy of Prince Jonah Kūhiō Kalanianaʻole, and affirming commitments to transparent, accountable government and stewardship of natural, civic, and cultural resources?
-
150 51.2%NO
-
95 32.4%YES
Charter Question #5 (Beginning in 2032, should the City use ranked-choice voting to elect the Mayor, City Council, and Prosecuting Attorney, allowing voters to rank candidates in the order they prefer (1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc.) in a single November election?)
-
154 52.6%NO
-
99 33.8%YES
Charter Question #6 (Should the Charter be amended to require the Honolulu Police Department to 1) adopt policies to ensure the constitutional rights of all persons regardless of immigration or citizenship status are protected, and 2) assist federal immigration enforcement activities only when required by statute or court order, and after the requesting agency’s identity and authority have been confirmed?)
-
150 51.2%NO
-
97 33.1%YES
Charter Question #7
Shall the Revised Charter of the City and County of Honolulu be amended to encourage increasing housing availability and preserving available housing as policies for the City and County of Honolulu?
-
150 51.2%NO
-
99 33.8%YES
Charter Question #8
Should the Charter be amended to clarify that the Affordable Housing Fund is a revolving fund, with repayments, interest, earnings, proceeds, and other receipts derived from the Fund to be redeposited into the Fund?
-
154 52.6%NO
-
93 31.7%YES
Charter Question #9
Should the Charter be amended to no longer require a second public hearing for any transaction related to City real property interests?
-
146 49.8%NO
-
104 35.5%YES
Charter Question #10
Should the City be required to prepare and carry out a functional plan for the development of affordable housing?
-
158 53.9%NO
-
86 29.4%YES
Charter Question #11
Should the Charter be amended to allow the Clean Water and Natural Lands Fund and the Climate Resiliency Fund to award grants to federal income tax-exempt non-profit organizations that provide services that are consistent with each Fund’s purpose?
-
149 50.9%NO
-
101 34.5%YES
Charter Question #12
Should the Revised City Charter be amended to allow the Clean Water and Natural Lands Fund, Affordable Housing Fund, Climate Resiliency Fund, and other funds established under Section 9-204 to receive funding from federal, state, philanthropic, and other sources?
-
151 51.5%NO
-
98 33.4%YES
Charter Question #14
Should the Charter be amended to increase the annual appropriation for costs related to operation, maintenance, and management of lands that were acquired using the Clean Water and Natural Lands Fund, from 5% of the moneys that were deposited into the Fund in the previous year, to 10%?
-
156 53.2%NO
-
87 29.7%YES
Charter Question #15
Should an Office of Data and Innovation be established to use data to improve city services, promote government transparency and civic engagement, ensure that the city uses artificial intelligence responsibly, and protect residents’ digital privacy?
-
147 50.2%NO
-
96 32.8%YES
Charter Question #16
Should permanent resident aliens who are residents of the City and County of Honolulu be permitted to serve on City boards and commissions?
-
148 50.5%NO
-
95 32.4%YES
Charter Question #17
Should quorum and board action be based on the majority of members eligible to vote, excluding vacancies and non-voting members?
-
137 46.8%NO
-
105 35.8%YES
Charter Question #19
Should the City Clerk be required to provide technical and secretarial services to the Charter Commission?
-
128 43.7%YES
-
111 37.9%NO
Charter Question #20
Should the Charter make a Councilmember, the Mayor, or the Prosecuting Attorney ineligible for election to any City office for two years if impeached, or if the official resigns after an impeachment petition has been filed, consistent with the provision for being recalled from office?
-
148 50.5%NO
-
94 32.1%YES




