x
Front Page

Powered by Unisys
x

HURRICANE TRACKER       
x

October 05, 2015 07:40am
Tropical Storm Oho Not Expected to Become Hurricane
EXPAND RADAR
  • Latest News
  • Sections
  • Videos
  Big Island News & Information Hub
> News View All
AD
ADVERTISEMENT

Sen. Schatz Opposes ‘Trumpcare’

Posted March 14, 2017, 01:14 PM HST
45 Comments
×

Today, U.S. Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawai‘i) took to the Senate floor to oppose Trumpcare, legislation that would replace the Affordable Care Act with a plan that he says would offer less care, impose an age tax and cut Medicaid while giving tax breaks to the wealthy.

“Trumpcare is one of the worst pieces of legislation I’ve seen in decades,” said Sen. Schatz. “There’s no doubt that there’s plenty of room for improvement in existing law, but Trumpcare does not improve healthcare for Americans. It implodes it. And that is a threat to the progress we’ve made these past seven years. It’s a threat to one-sixth of the economy. And most of all, it’s a threat to at least 24 million people who stand to lose their health insurance.”

Full remarks as prepared for delivery follows:

What do we call it? What do we call this new bill Republicans are rushing through to take away health care from millions of people? Is it Trumpcare? Or is it Ryancare?

Both of these men are branding experts. The president put his name on a line of steaks.

He’s put his name on a magazine, on hotels. And here’s the speaker of the house, who has worked hard to be thought of as a policy wonk and serious thinker, who has branded everything he’s worked on, from the Ryan budget to “a better way.”

But neither leader of the Republican Party wants to own this thing. And that’s because Trumpcare is one of the worst pieces of legislation I’ve seen in decades.

The process has been a mess. And this is despite the fact that Republicans had 7 years to work on a plan. At first, they were thinking about doing it without a score from the Congressional Budget Office. Then they realized no one wanted to vote on something without knowing how much it would cost or how many people would lose health coverage.

Now, they’re saying the score either doesn’t matter, or is wrong—except for the areas where they look good.

They’ve spent the last 48 hours trashing the CBO when there’s ample evidence that for the last 8 years, they’ve referred to

CBO as an expert source when it fits their needs.

Look—the legislative process requires hearings. It requires expert testimony.

And that’s not a mere formality. That’s how you get a decent product. And for all the complaints about how the ACA was passed, they had hearings. They had discussions.

President Obama even went to the Republican retreat and engaged.

Moving this fast without hearings is the kind of thing you do to name a post office—because it’s non-controversial. Or it’s the kind of thing you do for something you don’t want people to look at very closely.

Because every moment that passes, the coalition frays—if it ever existed in the first place. Now, you have criticism from literally left, right, and center.

And that’s in part because no one saw this coming. No one expected a bill that would look like this. During the campaign, this administration promised not to cut Medicaid. They promised that everyone—every single American—would have health insurance.

But here we are. And if Trumpcare becomes law, 14 million people will lose their health insurance by next year.

Let me repeat that. In just one year, 14 million Americans will no longer have the health insurance they were promised.

I want to talk about what that means. What will it mean if people no longer have health care? This week, the Washington Post featured the stories of people in a single county whose lives have changed for the better—all because of Medicaid.

In McDowell County, Medicaid has helped thousands of people get access to physical therapy and immunizations.

It’s allowed them to see a counselor for mental health problems and opioid addiction. It’s helped them afford the medication they need, instead of relying on free samples from clinics.

ADVERTISEMENT

These services don’t just benefit individuals. They benefit society by making sure that people are healthy and can work and contribute to our economy.

They allow us to save money by focusing on prevention instead of treatment.

This is what’s at stake. These are the services that will go away, because Trumpcare is going to cut Medicaid—by $880 billion.

Trumpcare is also going to impose an age tax that will allow insurance companies to charge older people more money for health insurance—a lot more.

And I want to be clear. We’re not talking about the elderly here. We’re talking about people who are pre-Medicare, but not exactly young. For example, a 64-year old will be charged up to 5 times more than a 21-year-old.

The older you get, the more they charge you—starting at 25 years old.

That’s why the AARP has come out against this bill. Because every year you get older, they will charge you more. This is an age tax.

There’s an important point to be made here about process—and that is this: This is not a health care bill. If it were a health care bill, it wouldn’t be in reconciliation.

What does that mean? It means that Republicans, in order to enact a health care law, would need 60 votes. And they don’t have them. So essentially, they’re stuck dealing with taxes using the reconciliation process, because it only requires 51 votes.

That means this bill is a tax vehicle. And so then the question becomes, who gets money, and who loses money?

And on that count, this is one of the biggest wealth transfers in American history. It’s a transfer from working class Americans to rich Americans. That’s what this bill does – it takes money from the people who need the most help, and gives it to the very wealthy.

Here we are in 2017, just a few months out from an election where income inequality was one of the driving issues.

And the Republicans take from that experience that their mandate is to go in and reduce taxes for insurance executives and for the investor class… to cut Medicaid by $880 billion… to cut insurance subsidies by massive amounts.

It’s like they were asleep all last year. Or maybe they were never very serious about income inequality.

We don’t need another election to know that this is not what the American people expect from Congress. They expect bipartisan compromise. They expect results that will make their health care better.

We can work together on health care, but it requires 3 things. First, good faith. Second, bipartisanship. Third, legislative hearings. And frankly, we haven’t seen any of these, because this process is a mess.

We need to have a conversation in the light of day, and let the American people weigh in. What is the rush?

There’s no doubt that there’s plenty of room for improvement in existing law. But Trumpcare does not improve health care for Americans. It implodes it.

And that is a threat to the progress we’ve made these past 7 years. It’s a threat to one-sixth of the economy. And most of all, it’s a threat to at least 24 million people who stand to lose their health insurance

These threats are the reason that the Senate needs to come together and say: slow down. Let’s work together. Let’s work on forming a bipartisan foundation.

Let’s have hearings. And most importantly, let’s not impose this catastrophe on the American people.

ADVERTISEMENT

Recommend this Article

Weekly Newsletter

COMMENTS

FACEBOOK COMMENTS

Jim Lusby Schatz opposes anything that has to do with Trump so what's new!!March 14, 2017 01:41pm
Byron Matthews Liberals are losing their minds, I love itMarch 14, 2017 01:43pm
Francis Chong And you are indeed the dumbest senator we have seen in years. Your lapdog tactics have got to be the worst we have ever seen. Can't you ever stand on your own like a real man should.March 14, 2017 01:46pm
Cathy Mathis And you must think Obamacare is fabulous ???? Give us a break.March 14, 2017 01:47pm
Teri Giordano Vollero Chris Murphy from Connecticut is his twin. And Dicky Blumenthal is their father.March 14, 2017 01:50pm
Fred Chestnut Kind of like how republicans treated Obama for eight years? Go figure.March 14, 2017 02:05pm
Fred Chestnut Conservatives are losing their insurance. I'm OK with that.March 14, 2017 02:07pm
Ashley Nichols What is the difference between Obamacare and Trumpcare?March 14, 2017 02:09pm
Tom Barnes one requires everyone to be insured, wether they want to or not.March 14, 2017 02:50pm
Tom Barnes Toeing the party line... waiting to hear his response to the Iowa representative that made some 'less-than-intelligent' tweets about growing the population with non-immigrant babies....March 14, 2017 02:52pm
Tom Barnes hhmmm.... we just re-enrolled for our health insurance. imagine that... Were you referring to the conservatives whose premiums were doubling under the ACA?March 14, 2017 02:55pm
Tom Barnes partisan politics at their best. /sarcasmMarch 14, 2017 02:56pm
Keith Snyder It's only the worst he's seen because it is from the other side of the aisle.March 14, 2017 03:12pm
Terry Karrick It's a good position to take. Bending over to the cotton candy head is absurd.March 14, 2017 03:16pm
Terry Karrick nobody said it's "fabulous", deflection drama queen.March 14, 2017 03:17pm
Terry Karrick Tom is funny, and doesn't know how insurance works.March 14, 2017 03:18pm
Terry Karrick Drama queen^.March 14, 2017 03:18pm
Chris Bufler Thank you Sen. Schatz for opposing Trumpcare.March 14, 2017 03:21pm
Teresa Jean Aipia Obamacare fell apart by its self and people like me , that have no insurance but penilized to pay huge fines at the end of the year out of my taxes. .. There is NO Trump Care , there are people working on a new health insurance bill .. it's a work in progressMarch 14, 2017 03:28pm
Teresa Jean Aipia Republicans never touched Obama care ,that is a democrat mess. Obama never compromised ,he did everything his way, just like frank sinatraMarch 14, 2017 03:31pm
Cathy Mathis Up yours trollMarch 14, 2017 03:35pm
William Arthur SO Sen.Schatz you say its the worst piece of legislation you have seen in decades. As compared to Obama Care it looks like a Cadillac health plan.And as you do not have to be part of it with your special Senate health Care that you use ...WHY... are you making these statements...OH RIGHT...your in front of a camera ..aren't you special...March 14, 2017 03:57pm
Yvonne Steenson Taylor So what recommendations would you make to improve one of the worst pieces of legislation or will you just tow the party line and complain about it? P.s. 24 million people may "lose" their insurance when they are not FORCED to have something they don't want.March 14, 2017 05:15pm
Les Miller Shut your Canadian poi hole. What piece of legislation have you authored at the state level? What meaningful items have you done for Hawai'i?March 14, 2017 05:16pm
Tom Barnes Terry, I wasn't trying to be funny earlier... But I am now! 👍🏼 Make sure to get all your lines in the water 😆March 14, 2017 05:43pm
Tom Barnes "my name is Terry and my last name sounds like the cat when it clears a hairball... you may recognize me by my id photo."March 14, 2017 05:45pm
Tom Barnes I've got nothing but time Terry....March 14, 2017 05:46pm
Marilyn Quaccia Then who pays the doc and hospital when when those who choose not to have insurance get sick? I say it's if it's their choice not to be insured then institutions need to have a choice about weather they'll treat you.March 14, 2017 07:16pm
Cyril Moniz Schatz is a complete idiot sooo....March 14, 2017 07:49pm
Fred Chestnut Tom Barnes - Watch it quadruple with Trumpcare.March 14, 2017 09:11pm
John Moyer He's pretty arrogant. I saw him up close during the Puna Lava-flow relief.March 15, 2017 12:28am
Randy Carter Shut up StupidMarch 15, 2017 03:13am
Tom Barnes ... and what if it doesn't Fred? I mean... what if health insurance doesn't go full-tilt expensive and people who want it go out and get it. And people are not forced to have it... what IF Fred?March 15, 2017 04:24am
Cyril Moniz Ya I've had a few encounters with him... all bad... huge anti gun guy too.March 15, 2017 06:47am
John Moyer I believe itMarch 15, 2017 09:39am
Mark Bergner By not typing "libtards" I respect your statement.March 15, 2017 10:23am
Matthew Fisk The ACA requires the States to review insurance rate adjustments, so if premiums are doubling iunder the ACA, blame the STATES, not Obama. If you're going to point your finger at least point it in the right direction.March 15, 2017 10:56am
Melissa Leilani Estrella Imagine that!March 15, 2017 08:19pm
David Austin Decades:-/??? You were in diapers 7 years ago ASSHOLE!!!March 16, 2017 11:07pm
Jim Lusby Schatz opposes anything that has to do with Trump so what's new!!March 14, 2017 01:41pm
Byron Matthews Liberals are losing their minds, I love itMarch 14, 2017 01:43pm
Francis Chong And you are indeed the dumbest senator we have seen in years. Your lapdog tactics have got to be the worst we have ever seen. Can't you ever stand on your own like a real man should.March 14, 2017 01:46pm
Cathy Mathis And you must think Obamacare is fabulous ???? Give us a break.March 14, 2017 01:47pm
Teri Giordano Vollero Chris Murphy from Connecticut is his twin. And Dicky Blumenthal is their father.March 14, 2017 01:50pm
Fred Chestnut Kind of like how republicans treated Obama for eight years? Go figure.March 14, 2017 02:05pm
Fred Chestnut Conservatives are losing their insurance. I'm OK with that.March 14, 2017 02:07pm
Ashley Nichols What is the difference between Obamacare and Trumpcare?March 14, 2017 02:09pm
Tom Barnes one requires everyone to be insured, wether they want to or not.March 14, 2017 02:50pm
Tom Barnes Toeing the party line... waiting to hear his response to the Iowa representative that made some 'less-than-intelligent' tweets about growing the population with non-immigrant babies....March 14, 2017 02:52pm
Tom Barnes hhmmm.... we just re-enrolled for our health insurance. imagine that... Were you referring to the conservatives whose premiums were doubling under the ACA?March 14, 2017 02:55pm
Tom Barnes partisan politics at their best. /sarcasmMarch 14, 2017 02:56pm
Keith Snyder It's only the worst he's seen because it is from the other side of the aisle.March 14, 2017 03:12pm
Terry Karrick It's a good position to take. Bending over to the cotton candy head is absurd.March 14, 2017 03:16pm
Terry Karrick nobody said it's "fabulous", deflection drama queen.March 14, 2017 03:17pm
Terry Karrick Tom is funny, and doesn't know how insurance works.March 14, 2017 03:18pm
Terry Karrick Drama queen^.March 14, 2017 03:18pm
Chris Bufler Thank you Sen. Schatz for opposing Trumpcare.March 14, 2017 03:21pm
Teresa Jean Aipia Obamacare fell apart by its self and people like me , that have no insurance but penilized to pay huge fines at the end of the year out of my taxes. .. There is NO Trump Care , there are people working on a new health insurance bill .. it's a work in progressMarch 14, 2017 03:28pm
Teresa Jean Aipia Republicans never touched Obama care ,that is a democrat mess. Obama never compromised ,he did everything his way, just like frank sinatraMarch 14, 2017 03:31pm
Cathy Mathis Up yours trollMarch 14, 2017 03:35pm
William Arthur SO Sen.Schatz you say its the worst piece of legislation you have seen in decades. As compared to Obama Care it looks like a Cadillac health plan.And as you do not have to be part of it with your special Senate health Care that you use ...WHY... are you making these statements...OH RIGHT...your in front of a camera ..aren't you special...March 14, 2017 03:57pm
Yvonne Steenson Taylor So what recommendations would you make to improve one of the worst pieces of legislation or will you just tow the party line and complain about it? P.s. 24 million people may "lose" their insurance when they are not FORCED to have something they don't want.March 14, 2017 05:15pm
Les Miller Shut your Canadian poi hole. What piece of legislation have you authored at the state level? What meaningful items have you done for Hawai'i?March 14, 2017 05:16pm
Tom Barnes Terry, I wasn't trying to be funny earlier... But I am now! 👍🏼 Make sure to get all your lines in the water 😆March 14, 2017 05:43pm
Tom Barnes "my name is Terry and my last name sounds like the cat when it clears a hairball... you may recognize me by my id photo."March 14, 2017 05:45pm
Tom Barnes I've got nothing but time Terry....March 14, 2017 05:46pm
Marilyn Quaccia Then who pays the doc and hospital when when those who choose not to have insurance get sick? I say it's if it's their choice not to be insured then institutions need to have a choice about weather they'll treat you.March 14, 2017 07:16pm
Cyril Moniz Schatz is a complete idiot sooo....March 14, 2017 07:49pm
Fred Chestnut Tom Barnes - Watch it quadruple with Trumpcare.March 14, 2017 09:11pm
John Moyer He's pretty arrogant. I saw him up close during the Puna Lava-flow relief.March 15, 2017 12:28am
Randy Carter Shut up StupidMarch 15, 2017 03:13am
Tom Barnes ... and what if it doesn't Fred? I mean... what if health insurance doesn't go full-tilt expensive and people who want it go out and get it. And people are not forced to have it... what IF Fred?March 15, 2017 04:24am
Cyril Moniz Ya I've had a few encounters with him... all bad... huge anti gun guy too.March 15, 2017 06:47am
John Moyer I believe itMarch 15, 2017 09:39am
Mark Bergner By not typing "libtards" I respect your statement.March 15, 2017 10:23am
Matthew Fisk The ACA requires the States to review insurance rate adjustments, so if premiums are doubling iunder the ACA, blame the STATES, not Obama. If you're going to point your finger at least point it in the right direction.March 15, 2017 10:56am
Melissa Leilani Estrella Imagine that!March 15, 2017 08:19pm
David Austin Decades:-/??? You were in diapers 7 years ago ASSHOLE!!!March 16, 2017 11:07pm
AD
AD
AD
AD

FairWind Big Island Ocean Guides
Voted #1 "Best Snorkel Cruise"
^