Front Page

Powered by Unisys


October 05, 2015 07:40am
Tropical Storm Oho Not Expected to Become Hurricane
  • Latest News
  • Sections
  • Videos
  Big Island News & Information Hub
> Discussion View All

LETTER: Hawai‘i Could Be a Sanctuary to Trump’s Immigration Ban

Posted February 8, 2017, 11:36 AM HST

Anthony Quintano in Civil Beat made a bold and courageous suggestion that Hawai‘i should consider being a sanctuary city. His article drew passionate comments from both sides. Of course, there are divisions. But I would go even further. Hawai‘i, or least parts of Hawai‘i should exempt itself from the travel ban and become a symbolic sanctuary for those suffering under the travel ban.

It is time to play the stronger “nuclear card” that Hawai‘i has—that because the history of Hawai‘i, particularly the failure of the United States to define the boundaries of Hawai‘i—the question has always existed whether Hawai‘i was wholly subject to U.S. law—the power of the president and the power of federal courts.

Yes, it is true, this is an argument associated with and put forth by Native Hawaiian sovereignty groups—but look closely at their analysis—there is certainly some truth in what they say. The borders of Hawai‘i are defined as “those islands acquired by the Joint resolution.”

Everyone, no matter what side they are on, agrees that such a description of Hawai‘i’s boundaries was flawed and was originally sloppy. Today it gives no guidance as to what islands and waters constitute Hawai‘i. If a unilateral joint resolution was the basis, Hawai‘i was made part of the United States. The power structure of Hawai‘i has ignored this largely Hawaiian argument so far—but what if what put into place in a limited fashion—to rectify an egregious wrong that the world is watching—and what if it was a reflection of the aloha spirit, and what if was the basis for a new identity of Hawai‘i, a new industry built around peace like Switzerland. Most important, we would be informing the world that the future of Hawai‘i, that is the economic future of Hawai‘i is built, not around construction and rail—but being the new Geneva, the new Switzerland.

One must ask how such would legal. The argument for an immigration sanctuary would rely on Hawaiian scholars who have worked endlessly and against the state, that Hawai‘i was never acquired by the United States. But the exemption from U.S. law need not be all-encompassing, the state government could limit to creating a small oasis for Muslims excluded from the U.S.

Of course, the Trump Justice would move immediately to quash Hawai‘i’s move—but the arguments that Trump rules Hawai‘i would be an uphill and long battle for the Trump Administration. Even if Hawai‘i was to lose—it would gain the attention of the world for providing a super-sanctuary no other nation or city would dare.

If Congress alone could make Hawai‘i part of the United States, then a law of Hawai‘i could make the U.S. part of Hawai‘i. If countries could, by a simple law, make another territory of their own—the world would dissolve into chaos. For years, both federal and state governments in Hawai‘i have ignored the Hawaiian sovereignty movement—perhaps because the movement required that all of Hawai‘i become the Kingdom of Hawai‘i.

One could take these historical arguments and use it them sparingly only at the airport. Suppose the governor declared that the airport and some areas around it were not subject to Trump’s travel ban—that those stuck in airports or in foreign countries by the ban could come to Hawai‘i—because the governor has declared that a small area of Hawai‘i was a sanctuary to the travel ban?


What if Hawai‘i allowed a few, well-vetted Muslims to come to Hawai‘i as an exception to the travel ban? Hawai‘i, then, would become the “sanctuaries of sanctuaries,” the “Pu‘uhonua” for the world—and establish itself in the eye of the world as unique and special. It would pave the way to the new future, the new industry, and the jobs for our young people, as to the economic and social future of Hawai‘i. Everyone loves to come to Hawai‘i—the most gracious people and most generous place in the world must stand up now—at least temporarily.

We are not in danger from these few vetted immigrants of the Muslim faith. We are the most militarized state in the union—there would be no terrorist attacks. The few we take in may be a housing burden but we are built on the visitor-tourist industry. The vetting rules, the qualifications for entry would be carved and enacted by the state legislature.

We are a compassionate people, all of us, military included—permanent resident Muslims are not a threat to the thousands of troops stationed here. We are the new Statute of Liberty.

Attorney General Doug Chin said Trump immigration ban is illegal and federal courts won’t let it be implemented—given that, what is a stronger case for us taking action—we know it will be struck down—we will not be embarrassed. Moreover, the law is so confused that while it is being litigated should we in Hawai‘i let Muslims relying on the previous immigration laws suffer? This new sanctuary is an emergency action to remedy a humanitarian tragedy.

We might be corralled to obey later—but no one in the world would forget the aloha spirit that is Hawai‘i which lies within us is directed at all people, whoever one worships. If TSA cannot enforce the ban—neither can the FBI, NCIS or military police.

We have the opportunity here to make a statement about our longstanding values of inclusion, aloha and respect for all. We might be corralled to obey later—but not one where the world would forget the aloha spirit that Hawai‘i dared to express in this e enormous instance of human tragedy. Law or not, doesn’t the aloha spirit look to the suffering of real people first?

Finally, we are not deliberately disobeying the law—the law, as Hawaiians say, has disobeyed the international and human rights of Hawaiians. Moreover, the law is so confused that while it is being litigated, should we in Hawai‘i let people suffer? An immigration sanctuary in Hawaii, where we control TSA and immigration is an order the governor can issue—for if Douglas Chin believes the Trump ban is illegal this new sanctuary is an emergency action to remedy a humanitarian tragedy.


Recommend this Article

Weekly Newsletter



Stanford Neering Really?? We can't even take care of the homeless here. Fix this first then think maybe doing that.February 08, 2017 11:46am
Les Miller What a stupid statement. Try feed the Hawaiians living on the beaches in tarp and box shelters out in Nanakuli, Waianae. First you chuckleheads take land away from Hawaiians and want to give it to more foreigners!? You guys are something else.February 08, 2017 11:57am
La Que Sabe Dean I think this was well written and proposed good intention and posibilites. I agree that we have a homeless problem here in Hawai'i and to fix the issue of homelessness Hawai'i should greatly consider alternative options to tackle this problem. The cost of living here is a great problem and that is what needs to be addressed. Creating more affordable housing options would help as well. Or just increase the minimum wage. There are larger issues that make remedying the homeless issue (especially in Oahu) more difficult. Everyone can pose opinions, but who's willing to step up to the plate and present solutions to congress, the state representatives, and senate? Maybe if more people presented solutions our government could get more supports and/or solutions to help resolve this issue. My thoughtsFebruary 08, 2017 11:59am
Kimberly Campbell Jordan Oh, hell no.February 08, 2017 12:00pm
Kevin Soulek https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=edVQETclhpsFebruary 08, 2017 12:23pm
Peter Jones What Hawaii lawmakers NEED to do is honor their Oaths and "de-criminalize" the Second Amendment here in the islands. Constitutional Carry.... All 50 States. Nothing less.February 08, 2017 12:52pm
Cathy Mathis We can't feed n take care of the people here now. Not to mention high crime n no reasonable housing. Any of you idiots who thinks this is a good idea please come hang out in Pahoa on The Big Island. Idiots.....February 08, 2017 12:57pm
Tony Miller And who's going to pay for it? If you haven't noticed, this nation is on its way to bankruptcy if we don't stop wasting our hard earned cash!February 08, 2017 01:33pm
Keturah Elizabeth Try feeding your own Hawaii!! So sad to see them offering when theres so many homeless.February 08, 2017 01:54pm
David Cozad As long as American company's can bailout and go to countries where they'll pay people next to nothing ,that's what will happen. And here in Hawaii I really believe we need to get a better education for our little ones, that's where the future is.February 08, 2017 02:06pm
Bob Wolfe Your kidding.... Trump's 90 day ban is not a "humanitarian tragedy". So all of the other countries that own Hawaii are ok with you "Hawaiian's", just not the people from the USA. Unreal.....February 08, 2017 02:08pm
Les Miller Word!✊February 08, 2017 04:06pm
Tom DeSantis https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ER43fQSUi5kFebruary 08, 2017 04:46pm
Stirling Conrad Sovereignty NowFebruary 08, 2017 06:25pm
Johann Peter Lall Hawai'i would benefit from Middle Eastern immigrants adding some diversity. Their culture includes some really good food for example. If you're concerned about refugees and immigrants, why aren't you worried about the 20,000 illegal immigrants in Hawaii?February 08, 2017 06:33pm
Greg McKee That does not actually show "respect for all" . . . if you think about it for just one minute. It shows respect for a chosen group at the expense of others. The pause in refugees from certain, specific, high-risk countries to make sure a workable and safe system is in place is a prudent and humanitarian approach. Perhaps you have other goals in mind.February 08, 2017 06:39pm
Jim Mattes As the old saying goes, "clean up your own backyard before worrying about others".February 08, 2017 07:00pm
Dave Kawika Anderson What part of violating federal immigration laws being illegal do you idiots not get?February 08, 2017 07:28pm
Kirby Faulkner Be a human and show compassion. Stop bitchin' and start pitchin' in.February 08, 2017 08:10pm
Blaine Stuart At least there will be a falafel truck on every corner...February 08, 2017 08:55pm
Lydia Walther Charity begins at home.February 08, 2017 09:26pm
Shirley Payne They do not eat oork and do not believe you should have dogs. You want to get rid of your luaus and spam? They try to force food laws on every public place.February 09, 2017 02:57pm
Shirley Payne They dont eat pork at all do not want it around them.February 09, 2017 02:58pm
Johann Peter Lall Shirley Payne neither do JewsFebruary 09, 2017 03:15pm

FairWind Big Island Ocean Guides
Voted #1 "Best Snorkel Cruise"