x
Opinion pieces, analyses and letters are intended to provide a diverse range of views from our community. They are not intended to represent the views of Big Island Now.

ANALYSIS: Raising the Minimum Wage – Truth and Consequences

· 3 Comments · Discussion

(x) Click to Close
What are the consequences of a minimum wage increase? Image courtesy EITC.
What are the consequences of a minimum wage increase? Image courtesy EITC.

COMMENTS
  • James Weatherford

    The people earning minimum wage will spend most or all of any increase in wages — which is good for the economy.
    Tis true folly to try to sell something to anybody who has no money.

  • syundt

    i resent the racist or derrogetory class types of “burger flipper” or “burrito roller” in this article. not everyone has the education or status to land white collar jobs these days and factory jobs that paid well have been shipped abroad. minimum wage only works if you can find a job that is not paid “under-the-table” which i haven’t found yet. i welcome a raise in minimum wage and a real legal job that pays 40 hours and has benefits. got any?

    • http://twitter.com/NateGaddis Nate Gaddis

      Apologies if the “burger flipper” term seemed racist. As a white male who started his career at McDonald’s, followed by a stint as a “burrito roller” and then dishwasher, I don’t find the terms offensive.

      One argument that we didn’t have time/room to include is the advantage of doing low-wage labor at the beginning of your career (be it at age 16 or 51.)

      The 16-year-old burger flipper illustrated here may not earn much, but is learning priceless lessons on work efficiency, customer service, and the dangers of hot grease. That pays serious dividends in the future, typically those early skills get rewarded with higher wages down the line (and less blisters.)

      Most minimum wage earners don’t stay in that bracket, and move up the scale over their lifetimes. A variety of things can keep them “stuck” there for a while, like family responsibilities, language barriers, etc.

      Or later in their lives, a higher wage earner may take a min. wage job after a layoff or other misfortune. But most likely within a few months or years they will have moved back up the pay scale again, assuming no major roadblocks (illness, etc.)

      It’s also possible that by raising that minimum wage high enough, you will force unskilled people (or those whose skills aren’t needed where they currently live) into finding jobs “under the table” that would never legally pay the new, higher minimum wage. To some extent, those low-skilled jobs could also be replaced by machines, shipped overseas, etc.

      What we “lose” over the long term by raising minimum wages is very difficult to measure. But it does seem that in the short term (be it months or a few years) raising wages will help low-wage earners without causing major job losses.